I was out cycling this evening when a man called to me in English, as if he was going to ask the way somewhere. I certainly don’t have all the answers with regards to directions in this town yet, but I stopped anyway; I still like to pretend to myself that I do.
The man began to tell the story of how he had arrived here from Iraq, had subsequently been refused asylum in the Netherlands, and would have to leave the country within eight weeks. Further to this he added that he knew no-one in Amsterdam and had nothing to eat and no money, and was desparate for help in reaching a friend of his in Groningen.
All this time I had been torn between fear that all this was a ploy to capture me off my guard before pulling a knife on me, and obviously sympathy for his situation. I stammered awkwardly that I didn’t have any money, which was not true since there was €5 in my wallet, and that since I too was a foreigner there was little I could do to help. He asked where I was from, shook my hand, and his eyes took on a desperate sort of resigned look; I suppose in that sort of situation you’re never going to get your hopes up too much.
As I cycled off I felt of course like the biggest arsehole in the world, and however much I try to rationalise things the truth is that I did deal with the situation in a pretty cold-hearted sort of a way. I’ve never given people in money in that sort of situation because in the long run it ain’t going to change anyone’s lives and if you give to one it’s hard to know where to stop; this is the best way of reacting I can come up with to what is after all a depressing fact of life.
Why was I so cynical and incompassionate? Why was I afraid of this man? The worst is that my reaction was perfectly reasonable, and there was just as much chance as any other that things could have got nasty. But in the simpler and more likely truth the man had come all the way from Iraq and its unimaginable horrors to the cold shoulder of today’s Europe, a place where comfortable yet frightened westerners tired of the world’s ceaseless torrent of poverty and misfortune cannot help but shrug their shoulders, offer nothing but kind words, and turn the other way. What damned, hard creatures we are.